Thank you all for those excellent responses; I have learnt from all of
them. Wanted to share this one in particular from an old friend called
Sagar, whose family has been instrumental in bringing AOL to New
Barrackpore, a suburb of Kolkata.
I feel we shd hv more such stories every now and then to stimulate the
intellect and deepen our spiritual experience. What say?
Jgd
V
Sent from my iPhone
>
>
> Dear Vikramda,
>
> My regards for choosing to open discussion on such a great subject.
> Here’s my take on the topic (it’s a dare given the fact that this is
> something that you also are struggling to figure). This reply is ju
> st merely my effort to unravel the story and I request you to correc
> t me and show me the way to understand the story better. Thanks agai
> n for sharing this story with us.
>
> (1) The Master is the Self personified. He is the window to the
> reality. Though he does speak, words fail to carry the greatest of
> the truth as the ‘word’ is also a vehicle, a component of this
> ever-changing flimsy existence. What remains of this ever-emerging a
> nd ever-perishing world is an innate experience of the substratum. T
> hus the real communication is in silence which is the truth itself.
> [Recalling the great quote “sach hain to sirf Guru ka maun”]
>
> That’s why Patanjaali had to impart knowledge only through silence a
> s that is how the experiential truth can be shared.
>
> (2) The veil signifies the limit of the worldly existence. As Sri
> Ramakrishna Paramahansa shares in a commentary with his disciples in
> Sri Ramakrishna Kathamrita, wherein he held his linen towel (gamcha)
> in front of his face and said ‘See, can you see me?’ and then
> removed it to show his face. Then he said, ‘This is Mahamaya. Pray t
> o her continuously so that she removes this web of unreal which cove
> rs the Real. With her grace only can we see the truth.’
>
> All our wisdom and knowledge reaches zenith at a point where we are
> just separated from the true Self by our body because beyond that is
> the realm of Adwaita, the truth. The Master is the knowledge because
> when he imparts those experiential truth to his students, he is
> sharing the fact that there is no second, all this and all that are
> the same. The intent disciple and the master merges into the same.
> The veil will thus remain as it denotes the limits to our existence
> in this body. As the shastras say, it will just erode from a thick
> fortress wall to a line drawn on water but it will stay.
>
> The burning down of the students signifies the merge, the meltdown
> because beyond the veil where is the master and where are the
> students. All is one and One is all. If the veil of worldly
> existence is removed, where is the world? So when the most curious
> disciple dared to move the curtain, where is he and the others? All
> he would find that “Sarvam Brahm Mayam”. Each and every atom is
> the manifestation of the same energy.
>
> (3) Why was the one boy forgiven? Why would he be not! The Master is
> compassion personified. This, I think, also signifies the fact that
> the Divine has left ways for this wonderful knowledge to remain
> within reach of us mortals. However disastrous maybe the scope of
> affairs, there always remains a way in this worldly drama for the
> ultimate truth to manifest in some name and form. Had the boy not
> been there, how would the lineage of the magnificent knowledge from
> Patanjaali continue to thrive?
>
> Also it signifies that a disciple with a good intent, care and
> reverence for the Master and the ability to cling to truth at the
> most precarious of situations would be given the knowledge. He may
> have to suffer from the laws of this world (as he did as a
> BrahmaRakshash) but for everybody and every being the path to ascent
> and exit will be opened in time.
>
> (4) The goat is most likely the manifestation of ignorance. Is it
> not true that when covered by the dark veil of ignorance, the
> greatest of the knowledge given is also treated with least
> importance and ignored? Here lying was the Patanjaali sutras, the
> godsent remedy to worldly maladies, somehow saved from the brink of
> extinction by repeated intervention by the Divine but to a goat it
> was no more than a few juicy palm leaves and food for the stomach.
>
> This signifies that the knowledge is different shapes and form is
> everywhere in this world but to the ignorant it will not be
> revealed. Though the greatest of the truth can always be seen by the
> Master everywhere, the seeker or the disciple can see it at times
> through Master’s Grace whereas the ignorant will be never be able to
> find or see it anywhere because even if he assimilates the greatest
> of these knowledge, it will never appear to him as an experience an
> d hence will remain a ‘concept’.
>
> (5) The significance of the story:
>
> The Master is the Reality, the Divine. Our journey to become humans
> and have this ability to perceive wisdom and use logic is proof
> enough of the benevolence of the Divine that He wishes us to know
> the truth behind this drama.
>
> Whenever the truth will be shrouded the Divine will emerge as the
> Master and will take us to the zenith of the wisdom. Few of us will
> wonder beyond the veil to know that ‘No Two’ is what remains. We
> are the same substance and the being which is the smallest atom and
> the largest star. The same Being which propagates the universe is al
> so the meekest of the insects trodden under an unintentional footstep.
>
> The other significant gesture the story makes is that the whole of
> the knowledge is not available for us to perceive in this form. The
> little forgiven boy was given the ‘rest’ of the Patanjaali
> sutras. Of that when Patanjaali himself came and wrote them down, so
> me of it was eaten by the goat and the rest was carried for propagat
> ion. Here comes the ‘wonder’ factor which Guruji reiterates time
> and again. The fact that one knows the part allows him to
> ‘wonder’ about the Whole!
>
> Sri Ramakrishna always used to ask his Brahma disciples not to
> illustrate the magnitude of the entire universe and its existence
> for the purpose of inducing devotion. He always claimed that we are
> ants standing in front of mountains of sugar grains. How can we even
> measure what the full is! The only tool for us is amazing ‘I
> don’t know!’ uttered in wonder.
>
> The other very important strain from the story is the fact that it
> reiterates the compassion of the Master. Consistently the Master,
> who is Divine personified, showers compassion on his disciples –
> right from gathering them, imparting knowledge, forgiving them,
> coming back to save them suffering from the claws of worldly laws
> and finally drawing on his own blood to write the sutras. Where is
> the knowledge without the Master! But for that we would all be goats
> chewing on tasty palm leaves.
>
> Lastly the story signifies that all these happen in worldcycles or
> Kalpas. The knowledge is there and it is going to stay. But from
> time to time the Masters will come to impart it to us and by their
> grace some of us will move out of this endless cycle of worldly
> laws. For others, the Master will strive to reach out the farthest
> and many will move ahead. But to the Master, none of these matters
> as he is ever sure of his presence and knows that in time, each one
> of us will move to perfection in some worldcycle or other.
>
> Jai Gurudev!
>
> Drop a line if you wish……….
>
> Love and regards,
>
> Sagar Bhattacharya
vinodkm says
Amazingly brilliant answers!
Can’t think of any better illustration.
Swami says
This is amazing knowledge! This only leads me to wonder as to what the ultimate knowkedge is. Thank you so much!
regards
Swami
Dharma :) says
Simply awesome..:)
‘Knowledge is mere juicy leaves to the ignorant’..this was the juiciest part…May be am still being a goat 😉
neelam sharma says
oho it is sooo wonderful ! Jai gurudev !
Priya M says
What a wonderful interpretation!:)Thanks for posting this bhaiya…
Sachin Chansarkar says
Dear Vikram Bhaiyya, No words to say anything….I still remember your words during the Ph1…that this path is like a staircase of a soap…with water flowing on it….& Guru is like a Railing to hold on…with firm steps to go ahead.
Thanks for this beautiful Blog for learnings.
Amit says
wow! so many different perspectives…nice…
…wat i learned…wat struck me most…the mind has a tendency to look at things as permanent…need to review again n again life in the context of time n space, to look the ‘fleeting’ nature of things….
Love
Amit
JGD!!
Balkrishnanitt says
Beautiful …
Uday says
wow! awesome explanation..just amazing:)
renuspeaks says
waiting n waiting n waiting for the next post in this series.
priyadutta says
jgd!!!!!!!! i cant thank you enough for sharing this post!!!! the most swesome post , I must say..:D
Aparna says
Amazing !!
Anshika says
What an amazing description..I got so engrossed while reading this! 🙂 ‘Amazing’ is the word..!
Jai Gurudeva
Sonali says
Wowow…superb explanation…with superb clarity of thought!!